Cundill Deep Value

Cundill Deep Value

DEEP VALUE WATCHLIST — FEBRUARY 2026 Hidden Assets. Real Catalyst.

FRAGMENTS's avatar
FRAGMENTS
Feb 15, 2026
∙ Paid

🔍 Market Context — February is the month of footnotes

January is when people talk.
February is when the papers show up.

In February, you don’t get to hide behind a good story.

The company has to open the books and show what’s inside.

That’s when you finally see the boring stuff that matters:

  • what they really earned in Q4,

  • what they really spent,

  • what they really owe,

  • and what the lenders are going to say about it.

A lot of the “nice” headlines don’t survive that moment.

Because February isn’t a month for speeches.
It’s a month for receipts.

And when the numbers stop getting worse, price often stops acting crazy.

Between the lines:
February isn’t about guessing. It’s about reading what’s already written.


🧠 Why this Watch List exists and what it is NOT

This is not a “top 10 to buy.”
This is not a prediction machine.

This is a short list on my desk.

Names where the market is acting like it doesn’t want to think.
It sees a scary label, and it punches the whole shelf.

That’s when I open a folder and ask the only questions that matter:

  • Does this company own real stuff?

  • Does it make real cash?

  • Can it pay its bills long enough for the panic to fade?

Because deep value isn’t “having a hot take.”
Deep value is noticing when price is saying something extreme — and then checking if the paperwork actually says that.

One rule keeps me honest: the walk-away line.
If I can’t say, in one clean sentence, what would make me walk, the name doesn’t belong here.

Between the lines:
Price moves first. The story shows up later and acts like it knew.


🪓 The February lie

In February, the market tells itself a few big lazy sentences:

Real estate debt: “It’s all broken.”
Not true. Some deals are bad. Some are just messy. But fear doesn’t sort. It punishes everything.

Small banks: “They’re all shaky.”
Not true. Some have problems. Some are just living under a cloud because people still remember the last panic.

Energy: “That cash won’t last.”
Cash is cash. The real question is simple: do they protect it, or do they waste it?

Cyclicals / consumer: “The bad times will last forever.”
Bad times always feel endless when you’re in them. That’s why prices get stupid.

Between the lines:
The best bargains happen when fear hits a whole group at once — and nobody bothers to separate the strong from the weak.


🧠 Method, How this list is built

A name makes the list if it checks four boxes:

  1. It owns real stuff.
    Things you can point at. Things that can be sold. Things that matter when fear hits.

  2. The price looks wrong for a dumb reason.
    Not because the business is perfect — because people are dumping the whole group without thinking.

  3. There’s a real trigger.
    Something that can actually show up on paper: debt going down, an asset sale, costs coming under control, results that stop sliding.

  4. I have a walk-away line.
    One sentence. No excuses. If that line happens, I’m out.

This list isn’t “what might happen.”
It’s “what needs to be true for the panic price to stop.”

Between the lines:
If I’m wrong, I want to be wrong small. If I’m right, I want the numbers to force the market to notice.


🎁 Free Preview (3 names)

Three names. Three different shelves.
Same question: is the haircut actually earned?


1) OSG — Octave Specialty Group

Why it’s here:
This is one of those situations where the market doesn’t really know what it’s looking at. The structure feels messy, the story feels messy, and price treats “messy” like it’s permanent.
That’s exactly where wrong prices live.

OSG isn’t a narrative.
It’s a clean-up job — and February is when clean-up jobs start showing up clearly on paper.

Catalyst:
Clarity that shows up in the statements, not in speeches.
I want the file to get simpler in black and white: what it earns, what it owns, what it owes, and what the plan is once the dust settles.

What would make me walk:
If every quarter brings new “exceptions” and new surprises — and the whole thing only works because they keep pushing the bills into the future.

Between the lines:
Confusion creates discounts. Clear numbers remove them.


2) BHM — Bluerock Homes Trust

Why it’s here:
When people get scared about real estate, they stop thinking in details. They just punish the whole group.
And when that happens, “asset-backed” companies can get priced like the assets don’t even matter.

BHM is on the list for one simple reason: the market can get dramatic, then forget to do the boring math — what the company owns, what it owes, and whether the cash coming in can comfortably carry the bills.

February matters because this is when everyone suddenly cares about the same two things again:
cash control and debt control.

Catalyst:
Clarity on those two points, in the statements.
Cash staying steady. Bills staying manageable. No weird surprises in the debt timeline.

What would make me walk:
If liquidity becomes the problem — not the headlines, not the mood — the actual problem.

Between the lines:
Assets don’t protect you by themselves. Cash discipline does.


3) SGA — Saga Communications

Why it’s here:
Small. Ignored. Priced like it’s slowly dying.
That’s the whole reason it’s interesting.

This isn’t a “radio comeback.”
It’s a simple question: does this thing still make real cash, or not?
Because if it still makes cash, the price can be wrong for a long time… until it isn’t.

February matters because it forces the only question that counts:
Is the business shrinking calmly… or is it leaking?

Catalyst:
A quiet quarter. No drama.
Cash still coming in. Costs under control.
And the company acting like it protects the money — not like it’s trying to impress anyone.

What would make me walk:
If the cash starts disappearing and it turns into a slow bleed you can’t fix with discipline.

Between the lines:
Big moves don’t start with hype. They start when the bad news stops getting worse.


🧾 Proof desk — what I’m watching in February

  • The fine print: the ugly notes at the bottom that tell you what’s really going on.

  • The bills: are they staying under control, or are they starting to pile up?

  • The surprises: fewer surprises is the first sign the panic is peaking.

  • Real transactions: if something sells in the real world at a normal price, fear starts to crack.

Between the lines:
The turn starts when there’s no new bad shock left to sell.

Everything below is the full build — the per-share version.

You’re not paying for “ideas.”
You’re paying for the file that lets you see what you actually own, and what can break.

Here’s what’s inside:

  • Anchor box per share (what you own, what you’re really paying for)

  • Asset map (what’s real vs what’s just fear)

  • THE CLOCK (when the big bills come due)

  • Per-share waterfall (stressed) (where the value goes when you squeeze it)

  • Bear / Base / Bull mechanics (how the math changes, not a story)

  • What breaks it (one sentence)

  • Proof-Next ladder — dated (the next things to watch in black and white)

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2026 JM · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture